Where in the Hudson Valley Contest: “Store of Lore” Historic Grist Mill

Once a dry-goods store, this building is more than 200 years old


In the midst of a bustling downtown area in Dutchess County sits this sturdy stone structure. Despite appearing out-of-place among the nearby shopping centers and strip malls, the building is the earliest evidence of commercialized industry in the area, the last remnant of a mill site that dates back to the 18th century.

According to the town’s official Web site, the building was part of an early grist mill, and was used as a dry goods and grocery store. Although the exact date is apparently unknown, records indicate the mill was already a properous business in 1795, and may have been built in the 1760s. In 1815, the mill building itself burned down, but the store was spared from the flames. The mill was subsequently rebuilt, and by the 1870s more than 40 local families drew a portion of their income from the mill. At the time, one-third of the 70 to 80 workers were under the age of 16 — and some were as young as eight.

The mill remained in business in this location until 1984, when its owner decided to move the company to a new location. There was talk of restoring the now-vacant buildings or converting the site to a shopping center, but both ideas failed to materialize. On July 21, 1994, the day the town board decided to purchase and restore the site, the mill fell victim to a second fire — but once again, the stone store survived the blaze. In 1995, the scorched remains were razed and the land was divided into two portions: McDonald’s purchased one and opened a restaurant on-site. The town bought the other portion and converted it into the Mill Site Museum Park. Now fully renovated, the old mill store sits adjacent to the park and serves as the office of the town historian — an appropriate use for a building that has witnessed more history than most of its neighbors.

Do you know in which town this early stone store resides? Submit your answer in the form below; the first reader with the correct response wins a prize. Good luck!

Give up?

Find the answer to this contest here.

Where in the Hudson Valley...?

Do you know the answer to the question above? Submit your best guess to our editors below; the first reader to guess correctly wins our prize. Good luck!

Full name:



Zip code:

Email (to contact you if you win):

Where in the Valley answer (subject/location):

Personal story or comment (optional):

Sign up for our free e-newsletters:

HVM Today: Delivered every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, our editors hand-pick the region’s top stories — from hot ticket events and pop culture buzz, to recipes and restaurant reviews, to the latest headlines and tips on living well.

HVM VIP Invitations & Special Offers: Get special offers on local events, products, and services we think you’d like.

Click here to subscribe to Hudson Valley Magazine (opens in new window)

This page requires javascript. It seems that your browser does not have Javascript enabled. Please enable Javascript and press the Reload/Refresh button on your browser.


Edit Module