Where to Eat the Best Gourmet Sandwiches in the Hudson Valley

The 12 most delicious sandwiches in the Hudson Valley (as rated by our editors and readers)

Gadaleto’s Jooba Doobie combines grilled shrimp, fried onions, and barbecue sauce

Photograph by Roy Gumpel





A sandwich is a simple thing, right? Not when it’s made by these Valley eateries that combine imported ingredients (Indonesian shrimp, sopressata from Italy) with locally sourced produce, and stack it all on homemade bread.

Is it lunchtime yet?


bread alone veggies alone

Bread Alone, Boiceville, Rhinebeck, Woodstock

From Bread Alone in Boiceville, Rhinebeck, Woodstock: Veggies Alone Sandwich


cafe mezzaluna cubano

Café Mezzaluna, Saugerties (NOW CLOSED)

From Café Mezzaluna in Saugerties: Cubano Sandwich


cranberrys cafe turkey chutney

Cranberry’s at Tilley Hall, Hyde Park

From Cranberry’s at Tilley Hall in Hyde Park: Turkey with Cranberry Chutney Sandwich


crumb chipotle cheddar

Crumb, Beacon (NOW CLOSED)

From Crumb in Beacon: Chipotle Cheddar Sandwich


gadaleto's jooba doobie sandwich

Gadaleto’s Seafood, New Paltz

From Gadaleto’s Seafood in New Paltz: Jooba Doobie Sandwich


j&j hudson valley blt

J&J’s Gourmet Café, Red Hook

From J&J’s Gourmet Café in Red Hook: Hudson Valley Chicken BLT Sandwich


lolas poached pear and brie

Lola’s Café & Catering, Poughkeepsie

From Lola’s Café & Catering in Poughkeepsie: Poached Pear and Brie Sandwich


mix n mac tomazzo melt

Mix N Mac, Middletown

From Mix N Mac in Middletown: Tomazzo Melt Sandwich


new city kosher deli pastrami

New City Kosher Deli & Restaurant, New City

From New City Kosher Deli & Restaurant in New City: Pastrami on Rye Sandwich


rossi deli pork roast

Rosticceria Rossi & Sons (Rossi’s Deli), Poughkeepsie

From Rossi’s Deli in Poughkeepsie: Pork Roast on Foccacia, Chicken Cutlet on Ciabatta, and Import Mix on Semolina


tango cafe lomo argentino sandwich

Tango Cafe, Saugerties

From Tango Cafe in Saugerties: Lomo Argentino Sandwich


village market philly cheesesteak

Village Market, Gardiner

From Village Market in Gardiner: Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich


Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module