← Return to search

Best Of

Keegan Ales

Map20 Saint James St.
Kingston, NY 12401
  • Food & Drink
  • Beer Story
  • Locally Brewed Beer


There are lots of great stories behind many of the Valley’s ever-growing number of locally crafted brews (and of course, drinking beer can lead to some world-class stories, too), but this is really a tale to toast to. A long time ago, before Beacon was even a city, the villages of Matteawan and Fishkill Landing had a legendary battle of the brews going on — and it was getting nasty. You were either a Frost Ale “Frostie” or a Justice Brewery “Man of Justice.” Finally, the wives of prominent brewer-businessmen J. Arthur Frost of Matteawan and Irving J. Justice of Fishkill Landing secretly combined their husbands’ recipes to bring peace to the communities. The result was an immensely popular brew from the Frost & Justice Brewing Company — which was busily serving until Prohibition. (In addition, Frost went on to become the city of Beacon’s first mayor). Fast-forward 90 years; when the Beacon Theatre recently was being renovated someone stumbled upon the original recipes of the beer company in the basement tunnels between the former Dibble Opera House (which became the Beacon Theatre in 1934) and the Hotel Melzingah. In honor of 4th Wall Productions moving to the theater, Keegan Ales craft-brewed a special batch of the F&J beer for a big fund-raiser this past June. And the folks at 4th Wall promise that, once everything is said and done, the Beacon Theatre will house a brewery tap room serving Frost & Justice.

Best of Hudson Valley History

2011 Editors' Pick — Best Beer Story (Frost & Justice)
2008 Editors' Pick — Best Locally Brewed Beer

Additional Information:

Best of Hudson Valley Winners: 2008
County: Ulster
Pick: Editors' Picks
About: Keegan Ales' traditional method for creating clean, frothy brews keeps even the most serious beer aficionado satisfied. Brewed and bottled in historic uptown Kingston, there are three distinct varieties for hops enthusiasts to choose from: Old Capital, a classic ale; Hurricane Kitty, a hopped India Pale ale; or our personal favorite, Mother's Milk, a rich, creamy milk stout with hints of chocolate.
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Business Listings

Edit Module
Edit Module