Mama Theresa's Italian Specialties
357 Old Forge Hill Rd.
New Windsor, NY
Best of Hudson Valley Winners: 2008
Pick: Readers' Picks
About: The DeStefanos, Jim Sr. and Mama Theresa, offer more than 20 overstuffed specialty sandwiches with such irresistible names as The Don and the How Ya Doin'? They all feature the finest domestic cold cuts and imported Italian meats, homemade sausage, and fresh mozzarella (you can watch them make it throughout the day). Very few people can finish them in one sitting, says Jim proudly.
Best of Hudson Valley History:
2008 Readers' Pick — Best Sandwich