← Return to search

Best Of

McGillicuddy's Restaurant & Tap House

Map84 Main St.
New Paltz, NY 12561
  • Food & Drink
  • Fun
  • Buffalo Wings
  • Reasons to Go Out on a School Night


This one probably won’t need too much of an explanation to entice you. With no buy-ins, drink minimums, or cover charges, poker tournaments at one of Ulster County’s more famous Irish pubs promises a good time. Oh, and did we mention $2.50 Bud Light drafts?

Best of Hudson Valley History

2015 Readers' Pick — Best Buffalo Wings

2012 Editors' Pick — Best Reasons to Go Out on a School Night (Free Poker on Tuesday)
2011 Editors' Pick — Best Buffalo Wings
2010 Readers' Pick — Best Buffalo Wings
2008 Readers' Pick — Best Buffalo Wings

Additional Information:

Best of Hudson Valley Winners: 2008
County: Ulster
Pick: Editors' Picks
Readers' Picks
About: Sure, there are 12 TVs, a pool table, comfy booths, and a happy-hangout vibe -- but the real draw here is the chicken wings. Choose from four heats (smoldering, volcanic, three alarm, or inferno) and 14 flavors, including Jamaican jerk, garlic, honey BBQ, teriyaki, or Cajun spice. Wing of the Week debuts a new outrageous flavor every Friday, and Monday is bargain night, when the wings are a mere 35 cents apiece. Get there early!
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Business Listings

Edit Module
Edit Module