Cold Spring, NY
The homemade ice cream here is simply delicious: creamy, bursting with flavor, and made fresh daily. While they produce about 100 flavors, 16 are available each day. (One of our editors is obsessed with the WalNutella.) But it’s the whole experience that elevates this to such a premium place. Sit on a cow bench or on the porch of this charming establishment just steps from the beautiful Cold Spring waterfront. To top it all off, portions are huge, service is friendly, and prices are reasonable. We’ll moo to that.