246 Main St.
New Paltz, NY
Best of Hudson Valley Winners: 2008
Pick: Readers' Picks
About: In a landslide victory, readers declared this Ulster County joint the greatest dough-slinger around. And it's no wonder -- owner Rino Mazzella tops his gourmet pies to suit every taste: from flaming chicken fajita to the legendary Grandma-style pizzas. That's amore!
Best of Hudson Valley History:
2008 Readers' Pick — Best Tapas